Home / Crops / Farming 'marginal' acres

Farming 'marginal' acres

Jeff Caldwell 10/16/2012 @ 1:49pm Multimedia Editor for Agriculture.com and Successful Farming magazine.

There's a lot of grain demand in the world, and there may not be enough supply to meet all that demand. Though some corn and soybean yields have been surprisingly good despite this year's drought, those are general realities this fall.

It's not a new combination of factors; tight grain stocks and corresponding high grain futures prices have motivated farmers to work to keep up, even if that means putting acres into crop production that have historically not been so.

"Our soybeans are not very good. Some are 6 inches tall, especially on the marginal ground," says Agriculture.com Marketing Talk senior contributor hobbyfarmer, who farms in southwestern Iowa. "I could point out many hundreds of acres out there like that."

The jump in these marginal acres moving into production reflect farmers' response to the increased incentive to plant more corn and soybeans. But does it provide enough incentive to justify the shift? It can have both farm- and macro-level implications on the market, says U.S. Commodities market analyst and broker Don Roose.

"If there are too many marginal acres going into corn, it changes yield potential, so it does create a little more volatility," he says. "Marginal acres will yield less, so there's going to be a change there."

On the farm level, though, they may not be the most productive acres; fields comprising less productive land may be farmed on the same cash-rent agreement as more productive fields, something that may not matter much to a landowner, says Marketing Talk senior contributor Mizzou_Tiger.

"They don't care because it's marginal ground that will not return on their improvements except in the best of years and prices," he says. "And that doesn't happen very often on marginal ground."

But market prices and land rents aren't the only ways that putting marginal land into crop production can eat away at a farm's bottom line. First of all, it takes more to get land that was previously idle or in pasture into production mode.

"Marginal acres need more care and maintenance. Not many know how to do that, hence the reason the ground was in CRP, hay, or pasture," Mizzou_Tiger says. "It takes higher prices to offset the risk and maintenance, not to mention the weather factor."

Oftentimes, like Mizzou_Tiger says, if land's not producing crops, it's for a reason. And, most often, that reason has to do with water and nutrients, says Emerson Nafziger, University of Illinois agronomist.

"Water supply is a critical thing, and most are marginal because they don't hold water well," he says. "Soil nutrient levels may be pretty low. They have to be pretty low for you to hurt yields of the crops that come, but when the main limitation is water supply, other things become less likely to be major limitations."

CancelPost Comment
MORE FROM JEFF CALDWELL more +

New Platform Puts Grain Sales Control In… By: 10/17/2014 @ 2:35pm Now likely more so than at any point in the last 5 or 6 years, getting every last penny you can…

Harvest Headquarters: Keep Up With… By: 10/17/2014 @ 12:24pm It's been cool and wet in much of the Corn Belt the last couple of weeks, but looking ahead…

EPA Report: Neonicotinoids Provide Minimal… By: 10/17/2014 @ 11:10am The class of soybean pesticide seed treatments about which speculation has swirled on its impact on…

MEDIA CENTERmore +
This container should display a .swf file. If not, you may need to upgrade your Flash player.
Over-Arching Issues at the World Food Prize