Home / Crops / Pesticides / Herbicides / Combat glyphosate-resistant weeds with the old & the new

Combat glyphosate-resistant weeds with the old & the new

Gil Gullickson 08/24/2010 @ 2:32pm Crops Technology Editor for Successful Farming magazine/Agriculture.com

Herbicide resistant weeds -- not just those resistant to glyphosate -- are continuing to wreak weed-management havoc.

“There are biotypes no longer controlled by previously effective herbicides,” says Aaron Hager, University of Illinois (U of I) Extension weed specialist. In one Illinois case, a waterhemp biotype is resistant to not only glyphosate, but also an additional three herbicide action modes.

The good news? Glyphosate (used on over 95% of soybean acres and 70% of corn acres) continues to be the cornerstone of most weed-control systems.

An online survey by Successful Farming magazine and Agriculture.com found that 92% of respondents are either satisfied or very satisfied with their glyphosate-tolerant cropping systems.

“In most Midwestern fields, Roundup Ready technology and glyphosate are still doing the job,” says Mike Owen, Iowa State University (ISU) Extension weed specialist.

Still, there’s apprehension about glyphosate’s performance. Of those responding to the survey, 55% felt it is as effective as it used to be; 45% noticed a decrease in its effectiveness. Meanwhile, 57% noticed an increase in hard-to-control weeds, while 44% noticed an increase in glyphosate-resistant weeds. 

“We are at the edge of a slippery slope over a deep valley,” says Owen. “It will get to be a serious problem very quickly if the system continues as it has without consideration toward stewarding the Roundup Ready technology.”

A disconcerting fact is that herbicide-resistant biotypes may be spreading via pollen. Research by Pat Tranel, a U of I weed scientist, indicates weed resistance to glyphosate can be transferred by both pollen and seed.

Pollen may move over a larger geography than seed does. Therefore, a herbicide-resistant biotype could be spread over a large area, just as herbicide-resistant weed seed can by hitching a ride on harvesting equipment.


How It Spreads

Doug Doolittle, Story City, Iowa, adopted Roundup Ready soybean technology early on. For years, two postemergence applications of glyphosate provided excellent weed control.

In a couple fields, however, he’s wrestled with waterhemp that’s become increasingly tougher to kill each year with glyphosate. He’s cooperating with ISU weed scientists with plots on his farm to find ways to manage it.

“You can brown it, but it keeps coming back,” he says.

Fortunately, the resistant waterhemp hasn’t been a problem in corn, as he applies Lumax preemergence. On soybeans, though, hard-to-kill waterhemp (which likely is glyphosate-resistant) prompted him last year to apply a rescue treatment of Flexstar when soybeans were beginning to bloom. This was after two glyphosate applications failed to kill the waterhemp.

The good news is the Flexstar worked. Those soybeans went on to be Doolittle’s top yielders on his farm.

However, the application dinged the beans and temporarily turned them brown. “Crop safety is important to me,” he says. That’s why he’s continuing to search for additional solutions.


What’s coming up

There are new tools coming later this decade that provide ways to manage glyphosate-resistant weeds. They include:

CancelPost Comment

Gil Gullickson Good idea 08/26/2010 @ 10:52am Grant, Good point on crop rotation. I remember talking with the folks at the U of Missouri telling me that one of the first glyphosate resistant weeds--either marestail or waterhemp--cane from a field that had been in soybeans for something like 10 years. so yes, crop rotation is a good cultural tool for mixing things up. Gil Gullickson

Report Abuse Reply

an overlooked option... 08/26/2010 @ 9:09am Crop rotation is a tried and true method of controlling herbicide resistant weeds. I'm just saying, don't forget the basics tenets of farming.

Report Abuse Reply
MORE FROM GIL GULLICKSON more +

Neonicotinoid Insecticide Seed Treatments… By: 10/22/2014 @ 8:43am I always enjoy listening to Mike Gray, University of Illinois Extension entomologist. He can take a…

7 Numbers You Should Know About Global… By: 10/16/2014 @ 1:17pm Fertilizer goes with your crop like a baseball goes with a bat.Still, there are places in the world…

7 Questions – and Answers – You Need to… By: 10/15/2014 @ 5:46pm Bill Stowe and Bill Northey both want safe drinking water for people in the Des Moines, Iowa, metro…

MEDIA CENTERmore +
This container should display a .swf file. If not, you may need to upgrade your Flash player.
Are We In a Climate Change?