Nematodes worming free of common soybean resistance genes
After almost three decades of shielding soybean plants from a deadly natural foe, the leading source of resistance against soybean cyst nematode is showing chinks in its armor, says a Purdue University nematologist in a university report.
The PI 88788 gene is found in about 97% of soybean varieties with soybean cyst nematode (SCN) resistance. The yield-robbing, wormlike nematode feeds on nutrients within a soybean plant's roots. The pest is linked to increased incidence of soybean sudden death syndrome.
SCN-related yield losses can reach 50% in heavily infested fields.
"Since the PI 88788 source of resistance has been around about 30 years you would expect there to be some changes in that resistance over time," says Jamal Faghihi, Purdue Extension nematologist. "We have seen that change occurring. The soybean varieties with PI 88788 resistance are not working as well as they used to."
What that means for farmers is greater soybean cyst nematode problems down the road, Faghihi says. Resistance failure in PI 88788 became noticeable in 2005 and has gradually gotten worse.
"Two years ago I made a trip to northern Indiana and noticed a lot of cysts on the resistant soybean varieties," Faghihi says. "We were not sure whether the resistant varieties did not work as well as they used to or if the resistance itself was breaking down. But it appears that the cyst nematode populations are changing under that source of resistance."
The problem is more pronounced in southern states and less obvious in Canadian soybean fields, Faghihi adds.
"Fellow Purdue nematologist Virginia Ferris and I have a collaborative research program with colleagues from Illinois, Tennessee and Ontario, Canada," he says. "We are studying the nematodes and different sources of resistance in different soybean growing regions. The research project started in 2005, and we've been collecting soil samples and accumulating data ever since.
"The preliminary data indicates that almost all of the nematode populations in Tennessee break down the PI 88788 resistance. In Canada there's much less resistance breakdown. And in Indiana and Illinois we're somewhere between the two."
There are few new resistance genes on the horizon to replace PI 88788, Faghihi says. Farmers can switch to soybean varieties that contain Peking and CystX resistance genes, however. Those sources of resistance continue to provide strong protection from SCN.
CystX is a patented technology owned by Purdue Research Foundation. It offers broad-based resistance to soybean cyst nematode by preventing the pest from reproducing on the soybean plant's roots.
Soybean farmers need to be vigilant in controlling the nematodes, Faghihi says. Those who have forgotten about the pest could soon be in for a rude reintroduction, he adds.
"We expect greater problems next year," Faghihi says. "The only way to know for sure if soybean cyst nematode is present in a field is to test the soil. Growers won't see the obvious symptoms. The insect is not flying at them, and they aren't going to step on it.