Fact or fantasy: Farm legislation need not prepare for $2 corn
The November 30 nearby futures close was $4.01 for corn, $10.80 for soybeans, and $8.85 for wheat. These prices compare to 2005 crop year pries in which corn brought a mere $2.00, soybeans $5.66, and wheat $3.42.
We interpret the current high prices as a signal that the market is bidding for crop acreage among the three crops. Last spring, farmers in the U.S. responded to the signal of relatively high-priced corn by bringing in an additional 15.3 million acres. Much of the additional acreage came from cotton and soybeans. Winter wheat acreage was unaffected because it was being planted just as the price rise began.
Our concern is less about the way in which U.S. farmers will arbitrage among the various crops based on price. Unless farmers convert a substantial amount of hay ground and pasture, the aggregate U.S. crop acreage is relatively stable.
As we all know, farmers worldwide see the same signals that guide the planting decisions of U.S. farmers. Nine-dollar wheat could grab the attention of European farmers, particularly those in wheat growing regions of the former Soviet Union. If they increase their planting and get reasonable weather, we could see a bumper crop of wheat hitting the world market next summer and fall.
Soybean farmers in Brazil and Argentina have already responded to the high prices by attempting to bring in more acreage during the current summer season in the southern hemisphere. For them, this year's weather conditions have been the factor limiting a bumper crop. Certainly they will try again if prices continue anywhere near the $10 level.
Four dollar corn certainly will attract the attention not only of Argentine farmers; it will also attract attention of farmers in many countries around the world. The closer these developing countries come to meeting their own needs for corn, the less likely they will need to import corn on the international market.
And then there is China. Certainly they will not turn a blind eye to the current high price structure. It is one thing to import $5 and occasional $6 soybeans. It is another thing to import $10 beans. Suddenly soybean farmers who weren't able to make a profit at five and six dollars can make a good profit at $10.00. Will Chinese farmers respond? We would not want to bet against it.
Combine the additional acreage around the world with decent weather and some gain in yield, and we could be awash with corn, wheat and soybeans, despite the demand for biofuels. And if we are awash with product, there is only one place for the price to go and that is down. We have a tendency to focus on current demand optimism and ignore future supply-response realism.
After the last price boom in 1995, prices slid for two years and stayed in the tank for four years. Could that happen again?
If it does, the Senate's Average Crop Revenue program will protect farmers on the first year down, and to some extent the second and third years. By the fourth year, the average of three years of low prices will offer farmers little protectionâ€”certainly less than the protection of the counter-cyclical payments under the current program.