Setting the Record Straight on Tar Spot in Corn
Nathan Kleczewski, a University of Illinois field crop plant pathologist, writes on his blog his concerns about the increasingly amount of incorrect information about tar spot in corn. Here’s his take on setting the record straight.
Tar spot on corn is the same as tar spot we see on maple trees.
False. Tar spot on corn is caused by Phyllachora maydis. Tar spot on maple trees is caused by Rhytisma acerinum.
One of the issues with plant pathologists is that we like to use common names for diseases. Unfortunately, that results in different diseases occasionally having the same common name. The same is true with downy mildew on Lima beans (Phytophthora phaseoli) and other downy mildews, such as those on cucurbits (Pseudoperonospora cubensis), and soybeans (Peronospora manshurica). Three diseases with the same common name, but caused by three totally different organisms.
Fisheye lesions are produced by Monographella maydis, and that is what caused fisheye lesions on corn this season.
Somewhat false. In Mexico fisheye lesions are associated with M. maydis. In the United States, M. maydis has yet to be associated with any fisheye lesions, despite assessing hundreds of lesions from different locations using multiple techniques. Just because something is associated with lesions does not mean it causes the lesion. In addition, we have a different climate and environment compared to Mexico and Latin America. It is entirely possible that another organism could be involved.
Finally, it is possible the lesions are caused by Phyllachora maydis and some sort of interaction between fungal population, the particular hybrid, and the environment.
Tar spot pathogens toxins that can hurt your cattle, etc.
Many plant pathogens (e.g. bacteria, fungi) produce toxins that help the pathogen trick plant defense responses or kill plant tissues. This does not mean that the toxin has an effect on humans, cattle, swine, etc.
Fungi such as some Fusarium spp., Gibberella, and Aspergillis produce toxins that can have severe detrimental effects on animals and humans. In parts of the state and nearby states, we are suggesting to test corn for mycotoxins because the weather was favorable for ear rots that can produce these toxins. Lodged corn also comes into contact with soil borne fungi that can produce these mycotoxins.
To date, have no evidence that indicates that tar spot causes ear rots or produces harmful mycotoxins. That should not prevent you from testing your silage and grain.
Tillage and rotation have no effects on the disease
Unknown. Nobody has conducted any replicated studies over many sites and years that have tested these effects. In addition, it is not known how far the pathogen can spread during a sporulation event. This pathogen overwinters in residue, but if it can travel long distance as spores, the overall impact on the disease at a local scale may be minor. This could be similar to fusarium head blight on wheat (scab) where, given the right environment, the disease can increase to a level where subtle management impacts may not be easy to discern.
Fungicide X applied at timing Y controls the disease
Somewhat false. We do not understand the epidemiology of this disease. That means, we do not fully understand the environment that favors disease development, how the disease spreads, infects, etc.
This season we have seen as many trials and fields where a particular product applied at VT provided suppression of tar spot, and the same product at the same timing had no effect. Conversely, some fields benefited more from later applications as opposed to VT applications. This provides evidence that the environment, and perhaps hybrid, are playing a significant roles in disease onset.
Until we understand the epidemiology of the disease and have data from many sites, environments, and years, we will not know if there is an optimal tar spot fungicide application timing, or if a model based approach similar to Sporecaster or the Fusarium Head Blight Prediction Center may be useful to make more informed and profitable fungicide applications to control this disease
Tar spot does not overwinter here
False. This disease has been in Illinois since 2015 and has been observed every year since, often in the same areas and fields.
We do not know very much about tar spot on corn in the United States. It will take time to generate quality data and information for the agricultural community. Plant pathologists in the region are working together to generate this information and share it with you as soon as it is available.