Will This Winter’s Cold Temperatures Kill Crop Pests and Pathogens?
Frigid temperatures that have occurred in January and February have been hard on livestock and the farmers who care for them. On the positive side, though, do they negatively impact crop pests and pathogens?
Below, Nathan Kleczewski, University of Illinois Extension field crop pathologist, and Nick Seiter, University of Illinois Extension field crop entomologist, give their take on the subject.
Many in the Illinois agricultural community wonder what effects the recent extreme cold might have on pests and pathogens. While it would be nice if the cold temperatures we are experiencing could help to reduce our potential for pest damage, past experience tells us that the most serious pests we deal with are unlikely to be impacted much by these conditions.
Many pathogens and insect pests that commonly affect field crops in Illinois are well adapted to survive winter conditions. In many cases, pathogens produce recalcitrant survival structures (e.g., cysts in soybean cyst nematode, oospores in Phytophthora, sclerotia in white mold). These structures allow the pathogen to survive extreme conditions including cold, drought, and flooding. Different species of insects overwinter in different life stages, including eggs (for example, western corn rootworm), larvae (Japanese beetles), pupae (corn earworm, though they do not survive the winter in most of Illinois), or adults (stink bugs).
The overwintering stage has characteristics that help these insects to survive the winter, either by adjusting its physiology to better survive the cold, seeking out an overwintering site that protects it (such as soil, tree bark, or leaf litter), or both. The overwintering sites that insects find mean that they are not experiencing the same temperatures that we are when we venture outside. Wind chill has little effect for this reason (even though it has a major, unpleasant effect on us).
Extreme cold temperatures can impact some insects and plant pathogens, particularly those that may not overwinter as well (e.g., powdery mildew). When cold weather pushes into the Southern regions of the country it can push certain diseases, such as rusts, farther south, delaying disease onset in Illinois and other regions farther north.
The same is true of migratory insects, such as black cutworm and fall armyworm, which do not usually overwinter in Illinois; colder temperatures during winter often delay the arrival of these insects, and may ultimately lead to lower numbers. The opposite is also true – warmer-than-normal temperatures during the winter can allow these migratory insects to become a problem earlier in the season.
Although cold temperatures may not impact most of the diseases we encounter in Illinois field crops, fluctuation between conditions of cold and warm may have a negative impact on some diseases. Dormancy by fungi can be broken by environmental conditions such as higher temperatures. This is similar to what occurs in plants, where warm weather may result in trees flushing out buds and flowers. Consequently, the wide swings in temperature that we have experienced during the 2018-2019 winter may negatively impact some diseases.
While some insects (such as stink bugs) can also break dormancy during brief warm periods, many of our most serious pests will stay hunkered down until the spring and avoid these fluctuations.
Unfortunately, insects and plant diseases are unlikely to suffer as much from the recent cold as we have. The best way to reduce the impact of insects and pathogens on those cold days is to stay inside, grab a hot cup of coffee, and curl up to the latest UI Extension recommendations or UI applied research results guide.